So, first and foremost: I do not want people recommending things like “Merlin with CLT” or any of the other “standard” answers. After all, those types of rosters are extremely common, and I see no reason to be a carbon copy; my roster wouldn’t actually be helpful.
Now that I’ve got that out of the way, on to the Servants in question.
I’ve been debating primarily over the Servants that I have in my All, Archer, and Caster slots, or more accurately, whether to have a Caster or Archer in the All spot. For Archers, I have NP5 Tomoe, NP5 Emiya, and I also have Ishtar, but she’s NP1 and I haven’t really invested much into her. For Casters, I have NP2 Waver, Tamamo, and Nero Caster. (I also have Merlin, but as stated, he’s rather common in Support rosters, so I’m not planning on using him.) I’ve been debating back and forth about what would be most important for someone borrowing one of my Servants, but I’ve gotten a bit stuck.
One the one hand, I have a ST Archer and an AoE Archer both at NP5. I’ve invested more into Tomoe than Emiya, both they’re both still fairly useful. I could put both of them on the Roster, but that would mean that I’d have to choose between the Caster Supports and the DPS Caster.
On the other hand, I have the big Supports and a decent AoE Damage Caster. I could put both of the Supports on the Roster, but then I wouldn’t have the DPS. I could put the DPS and a Support, but then I’ll have to choose between which Archer to use.
Really, I just want to learn what people feel is more important. Any help is appreciated.