For me, I’d like Euryale (since she has so much use), David, and Cu Chulainn (caster).
Honestly though, I’d love to see all the 3 stars get animation renewals but not so much the 5 stars because mostly all of them have unique animations already. I also kinda wish focus goes to old servants rather than new, like Melt, who has good animation already and doesn’t much need a renewal imo.
And I find the unique animations of each character really enhances how much I enjoy playing the character. For example with Kiyohime, I’m pretty lukewarm about her, but after seeing her animation renewal, it makes me want to try her out more often just to see the animations. And I love Robin Hood, but the renewal made me love him much, much more. I thank the Upper Echelons of Mysterious Workings of DW everyday for it.
But what do you guys think? What characters do you want to have an animation renewal and does the animation affect how much you enjoy the character?